Blog | March 14, 2012

Media Conference

Bill Moore-Kilgannon and Beth Podgurny at the media conference, March 14, 2012.

Treatment of 80‐year‐old is proof that profits and patients are a poor mix

EDMONTON Long‐term care in Alberta is in crisis and the privatization solution being pushed by the Conservative government will only make the situation worse, says an Alberta family whose mother was evicted last week from a private care facility.Grace Denyer is an 80‐year‐old who suffers from dementia, had a stroke in August 2011, has a pacemaker and is unable to walk and feed herself and has only limited speech ability.“Within days of moving into the Tranquility Care Home Inc. in South Edmonton, the for‐profit facility started to ask for more money. They wanted to increase the monthly rent from $3,495 to $4,995, despite the fact we had signed a one‐year contract for the lesser amount and they assured us they could care for my mother. When we instructed the home that we wanted to stick to the terms of the contract, they responded with an eviction notice, to take effect in only a matter of days,” says her daughter Beth Podgurny of St. Albert.“My mother was assessed as being in stable condition and designated as a long‐term‐care patient, but on the same day the assessment was made, the private‐for‐profit home where she was living decided it no longer wanted her and so dropped her off at a hospital emergency department without notifying us,” says Podgurny.“What has happened to our mother should not happen to anyone. It is clear proof that the profit motive and patients make are a poor mix.”Podgurny says she and her family have been concerned about Conservative government talk of raising the cap on accommodation fees for long‐term care to encourage more private, corporatized care.“Today, my family wants answers from the Conservative government. Why was it possible for our mother and our family to be treated in this appalling fashion? Why is this facility allowed to advertise for and accept long‐term‐care patients when it is not licensed to do so? How can they increase the rent in excess of 42 per cent within weeks of entering the home? How can they be allowed to evict and dump a resident at the emergency door when they decide they no longer want to provide care?”The family also wants to know why they have not had the courtesy of a response from an earlier letter they sent to Health and Wellness Minister Fred Horne and Seniors Minister George VanderBurg seeking a public inquiry into long‐term care.“We wrote to the Ministers two months ago asking for a public inquiry and expressing concerns over the treatment of our mother at the Youville Home in St. Albert. We have heard nothing since,” says Podgurny.“Because of the treatment our mother endured at Youville, we were cautious about trusting the care she would receive in a private, for‐profit home. Based on their assurances, we removed our mother from Youville and placed her in private care, even though we knew the fees would be a source of constant stress for the family. Little did we know that the situation was going to get far, far worse.”Noel Somerville, Chairperson of Public Interest Alberta’s Seniors Task Force, says: “The Premier has told us that she supports expanding the role of corporations in providing care to seniors. As we see from this shocking story, the province needs to protect our most vulnerable seniors by stopping these types of private facilities who decide they no longer want the bother of caring for your mother, your sister, your father – and simply drop your loved one off at hospital and leave them to clog up the acute‐care system.”“Unfortunately, this is not the only case we have heard of private facilities forcing seniors out who they feel are too costly to support,” says Bill Moore‐Kilgannon, Executive Director of Public Interest Alberta. “On the eve of a provincial election, we are calling on all political parties to commit to build a high‐quality public‐care system for the growing population of seniors with chronic health‐care needs – and to stop the profiteering off our most vulnerable seniors.” ‐30‐MEDIA CONTACT: Bill Moore‐Kilgannon, 780‐993‐3736NOTE: The Alberta Federation of Labour got to know the family of Grace Denyer while working on the recent Beyond Acute Care Conference in Edmonton. When approached by the family, the AFL agreed to help organize the media conference to bring this important issue to the attention of Albertans.Watch Beth Podgurny's statement to the media: